Response to edit

- Opt in for transparent peer review system

- manuscript complies with our policies and format
requirements

- we addressed editor's comment on manuscript

- we have added a data availability statement

- we do not use third party images

- mathematical notation complies with format request

- Their proposed summary:

"An efficient excitation of atoms by using photon is an important step
in control of photon-atom interaction and quantum information protocols.
Here the authors show that photons with an exponentially rising envelope
excite a single atom efficiently compared to a decaying temporal shape"

I would change it to :

"The efficient excitation of atoms using photons is a fundamental step
in the control of photon-atom interaction and quantum information protocols.
Here the authors show that photons with an exponentially rising envelope
excite a single atom efficiently compared to a decaying temporal shape"